Custom Box Inserts vs Off Shelf Solutions Which Is Better for Your Packaging Needs

In a 2018 survey, 72% of American consumers stated that their purchase decisions were influenced by a product’s packaging design, while 67% said the packaging materials were. Factors influencing this include the rising demand for sustainable packaging, increasing eCommerce sales, and growing consumer preference for visually appealing and informative packaging. 

Assuring the safety and integrity of goods during transit is essential in shipping and packing, where the choice of protective packaging significantly impacts outcomes. At Cefbox, our specialists provide professional advice and insights to help you make informed decisions for optimal product safety. Let’s dive in and discover the best packaging solutions for your needs! 

Understanding Custom Box Inserts

Custom box inserts include protective materials made especially to fit around particular certain objects. Usually constructed from materials like cardboard, foam, or molded pulp, they offer a custom fit that firmly holds objects in place.


  • Superior Protection: Because they are made to match the size and shape of the object precisely, custom inserts provide outstanding protection.
  • Enhanced Presentation: These inserts can be designed to improveenhance the unboxing experience, providing a premium look and feel.
  • Versatility: Custom inserts can be made from various materials to suit protection needs and sustainability goals.
  • Increased Brand Value: Custom inserts can be branded, adding a professional touch and reinforcing brand identity.


1. Higher Cost

Due to the intricacies involved in design and production, custom inserts typically require a higher upfront investment. While the quality and tailored fit justify the expense, it can still pose a challenge for businesses operating on tighter budgets.


Imagine you're a small artisanal pottery studio looking to ship delicate ceramic pieces. Investing in custom inserts to protect your unique creations might strain your budget initially, but it's crucial for ensuring your artwork reaches customers intact.

2. Longer Lead Times

Designing and manufacturing custom inserts require time and attention to detail, leading to longer lead times than off-the-shelf solutions. This delay can impact the efficiency of the packaging process, especially for businesses with tight shipping schedules.


Picture this: you're a boutique bakery gearing up to ship your artisanal cakes nationwide. Custom inserts designed to cradle each cake perfectly are essential for preserving their delicate decorations during transit. But waiting for these inserts to be made means you might miss your shipping window, leaving customers waiting for their sweet treats.

3. Limited Availability of Materials

Finding suitable materials for custom inserts, especially eco-friendly options, can be challenging. Not all suppliers offer sustainable materials, and sourcing them may require additional time and effort.


Let's say you run a subscription box service for organic snacks. You're committed to sustainability and want your packaging to reflect that. However, finding custom inserts made from recycled materials that meet your specific size and shape requirements can be challenging. It's like searching for a needle in a haystack!

4. Design Complexity

Creating custom inserts that precisely fit the contours of each product can be technically challenging, especially for irregularly shaped items. Ensuring the inserts provide adequate protection while remaining visually appealing adds another complexity to the design process.


Imagine you're a craft brewery shipping bottles of your specialty beer. Each bottle has a unique shape and size, making it tricky to design custom inserts that snugly hold them in place. It's like solving a 3D puzzle, balancing form and function to safeguard your precious brews.

5. Scalability Issues

Scaling up production of custom inserts to meet increasing demand can be problematic. Maintaining consistency in design and quality becomes a challenge as orders grow, potentially compromising product protection and customer satisfaction.


Let's say you're a growing e-commerce store selling handmade jewelry. Initially, investing in custom inserts to protect your delicate pieces seemed smart. But as your business expands and order volumes surge, ensuring every insert is precisely crafted becomes a logistical nightmare. It's like trying to juggle too many balls at once, risking drops and mishaps along the way.

6. Environmental Impact

Custom inserts can be more sustainable if designed with eco-friendly materials. However, the production process and the type of materials used can still pose environmental challenges.


Picture this: You're running an organic skincare brand that is all about being eco-friendly. So, using recyclable or biodegradable custom inserts is a no-brainer. Just think about those glass bottles of serum you need to ship. Custom inserts made from recycled cardboard keep your products safe and accurate, true to your green values. Finding these materials and ensuring the eco-friendly production process can be tricky and might cost more.

Possible Solutions

To tackle challenges with custom box inserts, businesses can negotiate bulk discounts, streamline design processes, expand supplier networks for eco-friendly materials, invest in design software, and implement standardized designs for scalability. For instance, a boutique fashion brand can collaborate with suppliers for bulk discounts, ensuring cost-effectiveness and sustainable packaging solutions.


This cute little bakery is down the street, famous for its delicious pastries. They want to ship their goodies to customers across town, but they need packaging that keeps those delicate treats safe and sound. So, they chat with their packaging supplier and score a sweet deal on custom inserts that fit their pastries like a glove. They also make friends with eco-friendly suppliers to get packaging materials that won't harm the planet. With some nifty design software and ready-to-go insert templates, they're all set to grow their business without hiccups.

Read More: The Power of Upselling and Cross-Selling with Packaging Inserts
 understand custom box insertspng
Source: cefBox

Exploring Off-the-Shelf Solutions

Off-the-shelf solutions are standard, pre-made packaging materials in various sizes and types. They can be used for a wide range of products without needing customization.


  • Cost-Effective: Off-the-shelf solutions are typically less expensive than custom inserts, as they do not require design and production costs.
  • Immediate Availability: These solutions are readily available, reducing lead times and enabling faster packaging and shipping processes.
  • Simplicity: Off-the-shelf packaging is easy to source and implement, requiring minimal effort compared to custom solutions.
  • Versatility: They can be used for various products, offering packaging flexibility.


1. Less Protection

While convenient, off-the-shelf solutions often lack the customized fit to provide optimal product protection during shipping. Since they are mass-produced and not tailored to specific items, there's a higher risk of movement and potential damage during transit. Fragile or high-value items may be particularly vulnerable when packaged with off-the-shelf solutions.


Imagine you're a small pottery studio shipping delicate ceramic mugs. Opting for off-the-shelf packaging might mean your precious creations are bouncing around like pinballs in transit, risking chips or cracks. Custom inserts, on the other hand, would snugly cradle each mug, ensuring they arrive at their destination in one piece.

2. Limited Branding

Unlike custom inserts designed to reflect a brand's identity and enhance the unboxing experience, standard packaging options offer fewer opportunities for branding. Generic boxes and packing materials may need to communicate a brand's message more effectively or differentiate its products from competitors. This limitation can impact brand recognition and customer loyalty, as the packaging is often the first point of contact with the customer.


Let's say you're launching a new line of artisanal chocolates. Off-the-shelf packaging might give your products a generic look that fails to capture the essence of your brand. Custom inserts, however, offer a blank canvas for creativity. You could design inserts with your logo, colors, and even a personalized message, turning every unboxing into a memorable customer experience.

3. Environmental Concerns

Many off-the-shelf packaging solutions are made from non-recyclable materials such as plastic or Styrofoam, contributing to environmental pollution and waste. Using unsustainable materials in packaging harms the environment and reflects poorly on businesses' commitment to corporate social responsibility. Additionally, the disposal of non-recyclable packaging can pose logistical challenges and increase landfill waste, further exacerbating environmental concerns.


Picture this: you're a conscious consumer ordering a set of eco-friendly kitchen utensils online. When your package arrives, you're dismayed to find it stuffed with Styrofoam peanuts and plastic bubble wrap. It's a stark reminder of the environmental impact of off-the-shelf packaging. However, custom inserts made from recycled materials would align with your values and reflect the brand's eco-conscious ethos.

Possible Solutions

To address the challenge of less protection with off-the-shelf packaging, businesses can explore options such as adding additional padding or protective materials to mitigate the risk of damage during transit. Alternatively, they can invest in innovative packaging designs that offer better shock absorption and stability, even within standard packaging dimensions.


Imagine you're a small online bookstore shipping rare collectible books. While off-the-shelf packaging may not provide the tailored protection these valuable items need, you could insert extra layers of bubble wrap or foam padding to cushion them during transit. This simple solution enhances the safety of your products without the need for custom inserts, ensuring they arrive in pristine condition.

Read More: The Power of Upselling and Cross-Selling with Packaging Inserts

Comparative Analysis of Custom Box Inserts and Off-the-Shelf Solutions

Protection Levels

Custom inserts offer superior protection as they are designed to fit the exact shape and size of the product. This minimizes movement during transit and provides enhanced shock absorption. For instance, consider a company shipping delicate medical devices. They might choose custom box inserts to ensure each component is securely held, reducing the risk of damage during shipping. The precision fit of the custom inserts offers peace of mind that the products will arrive safely, maintaining their integrity and functionality.

Off-the-shelf solutions provide general protection but may need to be more for highly sensitive or fragile items. The lack of a tailored fit can lead to increased movement and potential damage during transit. For example, imagine you're a bookstore shipping various book sizes. Off-the-shelf boxes and packaging materials can provide adequate protection for most books. However, the standard packaging lacks the protection for rare or collectible editions, risking potential damage that could devalue the item.


Custom Box Inserts

Custom inserts have a higher initial cost due to the design and manufacturing process. However, they can offer long-term savings through enhanced protection, reducing the likelihood of returns and replacements due to damaged goods.


Imagine a high-end electronics company investing in custom inserts for their products. The upfront cost is steep, but consider the long-term savings from fewer damages during shipping. Plus, quality packaging means happier customers and a better brand reputation. It’s like investing a little more now to save a lot and make a big impression later.

Off-the-Shelf Solutions

Off-the-shelf solutions are often made from non-recyclable materials, contributing to environmental pollution. However, eco-friendly options are available, which can mitigate some of the ecological impacts


Think about a startup selling handmade candles. Off-the-shelf packaging can help keep costs down, which is essential for a new business. But here's the catch: if the standard packaging needs to protect the candles well enough, you could spend more on replacing damaged items and dealing with unhappy customers. Those initial savings might not look great if you constantly handle complaints and pay for replacements.

Environmental Impact

Custom Box Inserts

Custom inserts can be made from sustainable materials, reducing environmental impact. However, the production process and material choices significantly affect their overall eco-friendliness.


Imagine a company committed to sustainability using custom inserts made from recycled and biodegradable materials. While these inserts might be more expensive and require careful sourcing, they align with the company's environmental goals and appeal to eco-conscious consumers.

Off-the-Shelf Solutions


Off-the-shelf solutions are often made from non-recyclable materials, contributing to environmental pollution. However, eco-friendly options are available, which can mitigate some of the ecological impacts.

Ease of Use

Custom Box Inserts

Custom inserts require precise design and fitting, which can increase handling time. However, once designed, they offer a streamlined packaging process tailored to the product.


Imagine a company shipping custom-made musical instruments. Designing those inserts might take some time initially, but once they're ready, packing becomes a breeze. The instruments get securely packed in no time and are prepared for shipping without needing any extra protective layers. It’s a time-saver that ensures your instruments are shipped safely and efficiently.

Off-the-Shelf Solutions

Off-the-shelf solutions are easy to use and can be quickly implemented, making them suitable for fast-paced shipping environments. However, achieving adequate protection might require additional materials and effort.


Imagine a busy fulfillment center juggling all kinds of products. Off-the-shelf packaging makes packing quick and easy, but you'll still need to add bubble wrap or packing peanuts for fragile items. This can slow things down and bump up your packaging costs. It’s a bit of a trade-off between speed and making sure everything arrives safely.

Read More: The Ultimate Guide to Designing Effective Packaging Inserts for Ecommerce Brands
 comparative packaging insert vs off the shelf bojpg
Source: cefBox

Factors to Consider When Making the Right Choice Between Custom Box Inserts and Off-the-Shelf Solutions

Choosing the proper packaging solution involves a structured evaluation process to ensure that all your needs are met effectively. Here's a framework to help guide your decision:

  • Assess Your Packaging Needs: Understand your products' specific requirements. Consider the level of protection needed, the nature of the packaged items (fragility, size, weight), and any special considerations such as temperature sensitivity or regulatory compliance.
  • Define Your Budget: Establish a clear budget for your packaging solutions. This should include the cost of materials and any associated costs such as shipping, storage, and potential waste.
  • Consider Your Branding Goals: Packaging is a powerful tool for branding. Think about how your packaging aligns with your brand identity. Custom inserts can provide a unique unboxing experience and enhance brand perception.
  • Evaluate Order Volume: Determine the scale of your packaging needs. For large order volumes, custom solutions offer better economies of scale. For smaller volumes, off-the-shelf options could be more cost-effective.

Read More:
How Custom Packaging Makes Your Business Stand Out
 feature image packaging insert vs off the shelf bojpg
Source: cefBox

Final Words

Global Packaging Design Services Market is estimated to be valued at US$ 24.63 Bn in 2023 and is expected to reach US$ 32.42 Bn by 2030, exhibiting a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 4% from 2023 to 2030. The decision between off-the-shelf and custom box inserts is influenced by many variables, such as the product's fragility, the shipping environment, the budget, and sustainability objectives. Custom inserts provide the best protection and branding options for more expensive, delicate objects, while store-bought alternatives offer a flexible, affordable choice for less fragile items. Businesses like Cefbox can optimize their packaging solutions to ensure product safety and customer happiness by carefully examining these criteria and regularly analyzing the efficacy of their packaging techniques. Ready to elevate your packaging? Contact Cefbox for Tailored Packaging Solutions today!

Share this story

"Share on Facebook"

Most Popular

Most Recent

Keep in touch

Get design inspiration, business tips and special offers straight to your inbox with our cefBox's letter, out every two weeks.


The Ultimate Guide to Designing Effective Packaging Inserts for Ecommerce Brands

View Details

Discover the art of Designing packaging inserts for e-commerce brands. Elevate your design game and captivate your customer’s attention!


Seven Creative Ideas for Custom Packaging Inserts That Will Wow Your Customers

View Details

Discover seven creative ideas for custom packaging inserts that will wow your customers, enhance their unboxing experience, and reinforce your brand's identity!